Menstuff® has information on
Incel - Wikipedia
Incels (a portmanteau of involuntary celibates) are members of an online subculture who define themselves as unable to find a romantic or sexual partner despite desiring one, a state they describe as inceldom. Self-identified incels are mostly white, male, and heterosexual. Discussions in incel forums are often characterized by resentment, misanthropy, self-pity, self-loathing, misogyny, racism, a sense of entitlement to sex, and the endorsement of violence against sexually active people. The Southern Poverty Law Center described the subculture as "part of the online male supremacist ecosystem" that is included in their list of hate groups. People who have either self-identified as incels or who had mentioned incel-related names and writings in their private writings or Internet postings have committed at least four mass murders in North America, resulting in forty-five deaths. Incel communities have been criticized by the media and researchers for being misogynist, encouraging violence, as well as spreading extremist views and radicalizing their members.
Male supremacy is a hateful ideology advocating for the subjugation of women.
Male supremacy misrepresents all women as genetically inferior, manipulative and stupid and reduces them to their reproductive or sexual function with sex being something that they owe men and that can or even should be coerced out of them. Driven by a biological analysis of women as fundamentally inferior to men, male supremacists malign women specifically for their gender. A thinly veiled desire for the domination of women and a conviction that the current system oppresses men in favor of women are the unifying tenets of the male supremacist worldview.
In their own words
Pussy is the only real empowerment women will ever know. Put all the hopelessly wishful thinking of feminist ideology aside and what remains is the fact that it is men and pretty much men only who draw power from accomplishment, who invent technology, build nations, cure disease, create empires and generally advance civilization. Women whether acknowledging it makes us feel warm and fuzzy or not, depend on men for all of that and the only tool they have at their disposal to have any sort of influence on any of it is the power of pussy and pussy is powerful indeed Sexual robotics may well prove to be the best thing that ever happened to women from the standpoint of their humanity.... what would that do to the vast majority of women who would suddenly have to prove their worth as human beings beyond simply being the owners of said pussy." Paul Elam, An Ear for Men, Sex Robots: Part 3 - Disempowering Pussy, October 2017
"Women, please listen to Whoopi Goldberg. If you dont want to be slapped, backhanded, punched in the mouth, decked or throttled keep your stinking hands off of other people. A man hitting you back after you have assaulted him does not make you a victim of domestic violence. It makes you a recipient of justice. Deal with it." Paul Elam, October is the Fifth Annual Bash a Violent Bitch Month, A Voice for Men, September 2015
"We've shouted endlessly at a deaf world that we were on the path to destruction, and we have watched our predictions of men being reduced to indentured servants to a malicious matriarchy come true, even as society continues to dismiss and humiliate us for speaking." Paul Elam on Men's News Daily site, quoted in Angry White Men
Make rape legal if done on private property. I propose that we make the violent taking of a woman not punishable by law when done off public grounds .If rape becomes legal under my proposal, a girl will protect her body in the same manner that she protects her purse and smartphone . After several months of advertising this law throughout the land, rape would be virtually eliminated on the first day it is applied. Roosh V., How to Stop Rape, Return Of Kings, February 2015
No means no until it means yes. Roosh V., 30 Bangs, March 2012
If a girl is in favor of abortion, there is evil dwelling in her soul. If you let her into your life, she will do her best to ruin you and bring you down to her level If a girl is so revolted by a lifeform that is genetically 50 percent her that shell go to Planned Parenthood to get it flushed out, she will treat everyone else in her life with the same level of cruelty. Matt Forney, Why You Should Shun Girls Who Support Abortion, Return of Kings, August 2016
No functioning, healthy society would allow Pulseor the kinds of men who frequented itto exist . No healthy society would mourn their passing. Indeed, depending on your perspective, Mateen was just taking out the trash, eliminating societal parasites via natural selection . When a man and a woman are attracted to one another, they are seeing the continuation of their tribe and the formation of the next generation... Babies are produced by heterosexual relationships; all homo relationships ever produce is cum. Matt Forney, The Orlando Nightclub Shooting and the Moral Sickness of Whites, Matt Forney blog, June 2017
Women should be terrorized by their men; its the only thing that makes them behave better than chimps. Matt Forney under the pseudonym Ferdinand Bardamu, The Necessity of Domestic Violence, In Mala Fide blog, 2012
Male supremacy was fundamental to the foundation of the racist alt-right, and in many ways served as its gateway drug. It is characterized by angry rants blaming feminism for the decline of Western civilization and deriding feminists as Social Justice Warriors." Personalities like "alt-right" facilitator Milo Yiannopoulos, conspiracy theorist Mike Cernovich, pick-up artist Roosh V. (a.k.a. Daryush Valizadeh) and Return of Kings and altright.com writer Matt Forney also constantly straddle the line between more formal alt-right circles and the male supremacist world.
Though male supremacy lives in a coalition of online spaces, its most established proponents are two hate groups: A Voice for Men, a mens rights website started by the violently bigoted Paul Elam, who has described men as indentured servants to a malicious matriarchy, regularly talks about the world as gripped by misandry (hatred of men) and called for October to be renamed the Bash-A-Violent-Bitch Month. The other is Return of Kings, founded by pick-up artist Roosh V., who advocated for the legalization of rape on private property (then claiming unconvincingly it was satire) and wrote that the path to saving Western civilization is repealing womens suffrage.
On these websites, much like on myriad subreddits, forums, 4chan and 8chan threads where male supremacists gather, the harassment of women is encouraged. In fact, this is sometimes a stated objective: in Paul Elams words: the progress we need will only be realized by inflicting enough pain on the agents of hate, in public view, that it literally shocks society out of its current coma or, in other terms, rattle the cage of feminists.
Gross mischaracterizations of all women are the bread-and-butter of male supremacist websites. Roosh regularly depicts women as manipulative, fickle liars with no life, who have to be battled and conquered, writing that the only reason very few girls are seen as losers is because they have a pussy, and just about all pussies feel good, regardless of who its attached to. Similarly, Elam has declared that sexual robotics would force the vast majority of women [to] suddenly have to prove their worth as human beings beyond simply being the owners of said pussy.
Male supremacy is an ideology with many faces. Its unifying thread is virulent, at times violent misogyny, and the practice of blaming women and a large feminist conspiracy for the ills of (mostly white) men today. Like other hate groups, male supremacist hate groups propagate conspiracies that see the world as a matriarchy propped up by cultural Marxism meant to eradicate or subjugate men. It is driven by the belief that men are entitled to a superior place in society than women, which are biologically and intellectually inferior as a result, any advancement that women might have obtained is nothing more than a usurpation. Like white supremacy, male supremacy is driven by fear and anger at the loss of white male status.
There are different paths and constituencies in male supremacist movements: between mens rights activists whose focus appears to be defending the rights of men, all the while decrying their infringement by women; Red Pillers, who claim to be the only ones aware of the existence of a feminist conspiracy running society; pick-up artists, whose goal is to lure women into sleeping with them, while constantly debasing them; involuntary celibates (or incels), who, having failed to find women either willing to have or to be coerced into sex, turn their anger into calls of violence; and men going their own way (MGTOW), who present themselves as male separatists and have chosen to remove themselves from the negative influence of women entirely.
The respectably named mens rights movement has roots in the mens liberation movement that emerged in the 1970s, which embraced female liberation and its critique of gender roles. The movement sought to free men from the constraints associated with the male gender role, which removed men from the home, precluded male emotional intimacy and made men their familys exclusive provider.
In the late 1980s and 1990s, however, as recorded by the sociologist Michael Kimmel in his book Angry White Men, this critique of the traditional male role morphed into a celebration of all things masculine and a near infatuation with the traditional masculine role itself. The problem was no longer oppressive gender roles: The problem was, in a word, women or more accurately, womens equality, womens empowerment, and feminism.
As women gained ground in the workplace and family structures loosened, some mens rights activists started blaming feminism for all of mens ills, whether real or imagined. The traditional masculine role was seen as either worth reestablishing, or, rather than being limiting to both genders, actually benefiting women. Mens rights activists decided to blame women (where others blamed minorities or immigrants) for taking away jobs, for the decline of the family, or for alimony and child custody issues after a divorce, rather than focusing on larger political and structural issues. The fathers rights movement served as a common entry-point into the mens rights movement and its focus on domestic abuse: large portions of the movement were based on resentment of women and sustained by junk psychiatry, debunked statistics as well as anecdotal evidence, as was recorded by Pam Chamberlain in a 2011 report for Political Research Associates.
The father of the Mens Rights Movement, Warren Farrell, gave voice to those feelings of male oppression in his 1993 bestseller, The Myth of Male Power, which has since become the bible of the Mens Rights Movement. A former National Organization for Women board member who used to rub shoulders with prominent feminists like Gloria Steinem, Farrell, after his divorce, declared men were as oppressed as women, if not more.
Though claiming to be equally dedicated to the liberation of both men and women, Farrell, in a section of the book called men the new nigger with the male role akin to the field slave or the second class slave and the female role akin to the house slave the first class slave. The book drew equivalences between slaves g[iving] up their seats for whites and men g[iving] up their seats for women, and paying child custody and taxation without representation. Women, Farrell decried, had become too powerful and dangerous because, on top of holding sexual power over men, they could then lead to mens downfall with accusations of sexual harassment and assault.
While some corners of the mens rights movement focused on legitimate grievances (male homelessness and rates of suicide, male conscription, lack of male shelters for domestic violence victims or some discrepancies in the family court system around the issue of child custody and alimony) to draw in followers, it then oriented those followers to who they believed was the root cause of all these issues: women, aided by a large feminist conspiracy.
The mens rights movement lives in a pseudo-academic, seemingly respectable bubble, using litigation to challenge female-only spaces or defend men accused of campus sexual assault though airing more disturbing ideas behind the scene. Often, these mens rights advocacy groups, like the National Coalition for Men (NCFM), founded in 1977, and on whose board of advisors Farrell sits, distort or cherry-pick statistics to indicate female privilege, blame women or create false equivalences between the oppression of men and of women, rather than simply seek to advance the cause of men and fathers. Groups like NCFM use litigation to challenge what they perceived as discrimination in favor of women and try to influence policy on domestic violence, sexual assault, divorce and custody cases. In reality, they offered little help to men other than blaming women or advocating to deny women the structures that they did have to resort to discrimination or violence one of the biggest grievances of the mens rights movement, for instance, is the Violence Against Women Act in 1994.
The mens rights movement has a dedicated international following, including in the United Kingdom and in Australia. Women, too, have helped give the mens rights movement a veneer of even-handedness. Prominent MRAs also include anti-feminist female voices, such as popular Canadian YouTube personality Karen Straughan, American psychologist Helen Smith, and the former head of a domestic-violence shelter for women, the British Erin Pizzey. Mens rights issues also overlap with the rhetoric of equity feminists like Christina Hoff Sommers, who give a mainstream and respectable face to some MRA concerns.
Most recently, Cassie Jaye, an American documentary filmmaker became a mens rights activist after producing The Red Pill documentary, a foray into the world of mens rights activists. As David Futrelle, who monitors the manosphere on his blog We Hunted the Mammoth, decried, Jaye accepted funding directly from MRAs, notably taking money from Paul Elam and from regulars of the violently anti-woman The Red Pill subreddit, a misogynistic forum on Reddit. The misogynistic conspiracy theorist, Mike Cernovich, donated $10,000 to become an associate producer. The documentary, which sees Jaye interviewing MRAs and never challenging them on their myriad of misogynistic positions, sparked outrage in Australia. A campaign denouncing it as misogynistic propaganda succeeded in getting the film dropped by an Australian cinema. In the US, The Village Voice reportedly refused to run paid ads for the film in its paper.
Prominently featured in the film is rape apologist Paul Elam, the founder of one of the most virulent misogynistic websites feeding the mens rights activist movement, A Voice for Men (AVFM). It publishes a plethora of writers decrying feminism and blaming women for a diversity of ills, often with violent rhetoric. Elam, one of the most public faces of the mens rights movement, is most famously known for declaring October to be Bash a Violent Bitch month he later called the piece satirical but has been republishing it every October with equally violent introductions. He has claimed that were he to serve on a jury for a men accused of rape, he would automatically declare the defendant not guilty, regardless of the facts of the case.
Founded in 2009, AVFM and its podcast Ear for Men combines mens rights issues and rabidly misogynistic and violent rhetoric. Elams writing and interventions make no mystery of his delight in violent fantasies against women. In 2011, A Voice for Men launched Register-Her, a website listing women alongside their picture who they argued belong in prison (the website has since been taken down). It included women deemed to have falsely accused men of rape or domestic violence, others for having protested mens rights activist gatherings, or those Elam simply disagreed with. The effect of Register-Her was an explosion of online harassment. After finding herself targeted, feminist writer Jessica Valenti was forced to leave her home in fear of her safety. Elam, catering to these hordes of harassers, had no qualms egging them on.
Elam remains at the center of the contemporary mens rights movement, however: he hosts the yearly international conference on mens issues bringing together mens rights activists from various countries. He is also a close friend and protégé of Warren Farrell. Elam has defended his foulest writings as ways to bring attention to the mens rights issues that AVFM features. And though Farrell himself told Mother Jones that harassment and violent rhetoric made him uncomfortable, he too asserted that they were strategically necessary:
Ive seen how Martin Luther King alone was dismissed. It took Stokely Carmichael and Eldridge Cleaver to say things that were pretty ridiculous in some ways, but that brought the attention that led to Martin Luther King being seen as the nice, centered, balanced person.
Roosh, pick up artists and the red pill
One of the defining strands of online male supremacist movements is pick-up artistry. Pick Up Artists (PUA) have focused on teaching men how to manipulate women into sex, all the while constantly disparaging women and the idea of consent.
The most prominent PUA is Roosh V. who has called for the legalization of rape on private property on his popular website, Return of Kings, founded in October 2012. Roosh has repeatedly boasted of raping women in his Bang books, accounts of which were collected by David Futrelle on his website, We Hunted the Mammoth. A website festering with misogyny and incitements to rape, Return of King headlines have included When Her No Means Yes, The Intellectual Inferiority of Women, Why Women Shouldnt Work or Dont Let Your Girlfriends Have Homosexual Friends. Roosh has organized a fat shaming week to coerce women into losing weight.
Roosh easily qualifies as both the most visible pick-up artist in the world, with his videos regularly reaching 30,000 views. He has a combined Twitter following of over 55,000 as of January 2018. In 2016, Roosh organized a series of meet-ups in 43 countries, leading thousands of people in various countries to petition their government to ban Roosh from their countries. Some 58,000 people signed a petition to ban Roosh from Scotland and 92,000 people signed a petition to ban him from the UK. Since then, he was reportedly banned from the UK.
Initially coming out of an industry emboldening men to seduce women, according to Alex DiBranco, a Ph.D. candidate in sociology at Yale University who had written on male supremacy for Political Research Associates, pick-up artists and mens rights activists have increasingly become muddled in the online space, especially with the emergence of the Red Pill subreddit, a virulent misogynistic subreddit which includes over 245,500 subscribers as of January 2018.
Set up by Republican New Hampshire state representative Robert Fisher, who resigned from his seat when he was revealed to be the pages creator, the Red Pill is chock full of misogynistic comment, coming from all corners of male supremacy. Fisher, who asserted that rape wasnt all bad because the rapist enjoyed it, wrote that women were inferior to men intellectually, that only their bodies made them worth it and that feminists (or most women) actually want to be dominated and raped.
Though Roosh is perhaps one of the most well-known pick up artists, scores of pick-up artistry niches have developed online, from subreddits like /Seduction (264,026 readers in January 2018) to online forums like pick-up-artist-forum.com, some of which offer sometimes expensive courses to teach men how to lure women into sex. However, their often predatory, cruel and inconsequential advice on how to manipulate women sometimes disappoints its practitioners. Men who felt deceived by these seduction methods but still felt entitled to sexual attention from women eventually gathered on the now defunct anti-PUA website PUAhate, or the still live Sluthate.com. They call themselves involuntary celibates, or incels.
The violence so omnipresent in PUA hate first made headlines in 2014: the website was frequented by Elliot Rodger, whose misogynistic, hate-filled rants, which he attributed to his rejection by women, eventually led him to murder six people and injure fourteen in Isla Vista, California.
It was on PUAHate that Rodger found a forum full of men who are starved of sex, just like me. It confirmed many of the theories I had about how wicked and degenerate women really are. In his 140-page manifesto, he declared:
This whole viewpoint and ideology of abolishing sex stems from being deprived of it all my life. If I cannot have it, I will do everything I can to DESTROY IT. My orchestration of the Day of Retribution is my attempt to do everything, in my power, to destroy everything I cannot have. All of those beautiful girls Ive desired so much in my life, but can never have because they despise and loathe me, I will destroy. All of those popular people who live hedonistic lives of pleasure, I will destroy, because they never accepted me as one of them. I will kill them all and make them suffer, just as they have made me suffer. It is only fair.
While Rodger represents an extreme case, the kind of violence and hatred that led Rodger to action was not particularly surprising given the nature of the incel community. Incels, who luxuriate in their hatred of women, found a home for their hate-filled, misogynistic rants. One of the incel communitys common complaints is that women prefer Chads (empty-headed, good-looking men) to nice men like incels, and for this they deserve punishment. The violent rhetoric of this community finally led to the banning of the /incel subreddit which claimed some 40,000 subscribers in November 2017. The now banned subreddit had long featured content like posts entitled all women are sluts. Participants often decried womens lack of brain capacity, genetic inferiority, cruelty, or designated women by the terms "femoids" or even, poetically, "cum dumpsters.
Revealingly, since the Isla Vista shooting, Rodger is sometimes referred to by incel communities as St. Elliott. A Salon overview of incel blogs shows support for Rodger in many corners of the incel community. One, called That Incel blogger, wrote:
What happened is punishment for evil and violence of feminists and liberals. Any of you supporting atrocities like womens suffrage, immodest clothing, child support/alimony, no ban on adultery, ban on prostitution and a lack of female premarital chastity, all the things that drove this young man to be unable to find a girlfriend, are disgusting, horrible people and you created a culture where this is possible.
Rodger is not the first to have committed deadly violence in the name of male supremacy: in fact, his bloodshed is referred to as going Sodini, after the murder of three women by George Sodini at a Pittsburgh gym. Along with Norwegian Anders Behring Breivik, who slaughtered while 77 decrying feminism and divorce on demand in his manifesto, misogynistic violence has taken many lives in the U.S. and abroad.
On the borders of the hateful incel community, a community advocating for male separatism has also emerged: calling themselves MGTOW, Men Going Their Own Way, these men decided to withdraw themselves from the toxicity of women increasingly, eventually going monk by abstaining from sex altogether. Decried by Roosh as passive and meek, they also deem women inferior and harmful and think they get in the way of male achievement.
Though male supremacy has very much found a comfortable home on incel and PUA spaces and on The Red Pill, as Robert Fisher wrote under his pseudonym redpillschool, it is only one of the domains where misogyny thrives on the far-right:
There's a reason the_donald, gamer-gate, and other groups have adopted the phrase "red pill." It really doesn't apply to only sexual strategy. But that doesn't devalue the phrase "red pill" since the thread that ties ALL of these groups together is a mutual disdain for feminism (and by extension the liberals who use feminism to push their racism and communism).
Gamergate and online harassment
TRP is only the tip of a vibrant but hateful online subculture, where mens rights activists who have taken the red pill now see male oppression everywhere they turn. A constellation of anti-woman websites, subreddits, blogs, and forums constitute the so-called manosphere. Several harassment campaigns have emerged from these loosely defined communities, all of which are united by misogyny.
The capacity for online harassment among this subculture rushed into full view during the 2014 #Gamergate campaign. Ignited by a blog-post by an ex-boyfriend of female video game developer Zoë Quinn which led to unfounded accusations that Quinn had slept with men in return for positive coverage of her game #Gamergate turned into a full-blown campaign of harassment against women in the video game industry.
Coordinated from gaming platforms to image boards like 4chan to Reddit and YouTube, the campaign was defined by digital death and rape threats. Fueled by a familiar male supremacist narrative, some gamergaters claimed to be motivated by their indignation over the supposed collusion between media industries and feminism, rather than by misogyny.
Though many attribute the intensification of male supremacy to #Gamergate, DiBranco instead sees Gamergate as significant in that it brought some leaders to the movement. Rather than broadening the base of male supremacist networks, #Gamergate helped to propel into the mainstream virulently anti-feminist personalities, most prominently Breitbarts "alt-right" launderer Milo Yiannopoulos and conspiracy theorist Mike Cernovich. As DiBranco writes, Yiannopoulos and Cernovich rose to prominence primarily on their misogynist rhetoric. Yiannopoulos seized onto the #Gamergate controversy to voice his support of Gamergaters against sociopathic feminist programmers and campaigners, adding to his rich bibliography of anti-feminist and sexist comments.
Cernovich, too, is another career misogynist: his first blog Danger and Play (The true man wants two things: danger and play. For that reason he wants woman, as the most dangerous plaything) offered such dating advice as Misogyny gets you laid. Soon, Cernovich also cheered on #Gamergate, calling it the most important battle of the culture war this century. According to Roosh, Cernovich obtained Quinns legal complaint against her ex-boyfriend and gave it to Roosh so that he could write a piece attacking Quinn on his popular website Return of Kings.
In An Establishment Conservatives Guide to the Alt-Right, Yiannopoulos and his co-writer, Allum Bokhari, wrote that the so-called online manosphere, the nemeses of left-wing feminism, quickly became one of the alt-rights most distinctive constituencies. As a Buzzfeed article revealed, Yiannopoulos invited neo-Nazis, white nationalists and members of the alt-right direct access to the editing process.
A tight overlap exists between the "alt-right," white supremacist and male supremacist circles, which feed each others narratives of the dispossession and oppression of white men, which is blamed on minorities, immigrants and women. Both the alt-right and the manosphere agree that feminism is the cause of Western civilizational decline. In fact, the misogyny intrinsic to the "alt-right" might very well be one of its distinctive feature, or a gateway drug.
Xenophobia and racism had found a home in some corners of the mens rights activist movement from the beginning. Fathers Manifesto, an early fathers rights group, included a call to exile blacks from the country on its website. The National Coalition for Men protested that undocumented people could use the Violence Against Women Act to stay in the U.S. In male supremacist subreddits, whether /TheRedPill, /incels, /MGTOW or others, xenophobic rhetoric abounds.
The overlap between "alt-right" and manosphere can be seen among several far-right figureheads: Christopher Cantwell, the neo-Nazi arrested at Charlottesville, once wrote for A Voice for Men. He also interviewed MRA Karen Straughan for his website, Radical Agenda. In August 2017, some "alt-right" activists organized a Make Men Great Again conference. Matt Forney, a prominent racist and sexist writer at Return of Kings who has written that raping or beating women is often justified (or that feminists actually want to be raped), now writes on alt-right.com.
The overlap isnt surprising: indeed, Return of Kings regularly spouts anti-immigrant rhetoric (although it is open to attractive female immigrants.) Its founder, the widely reviled Roosh, positively reviewed the influential book from "alt-right" and antisemitic Kevin MacDonald. In 2015, Roosh spoke at Richard Spencers National Policy Institute. Soon enough, the backlash to Rooshs presence in the "alt-right", as a non-white man who had sexual contact with white women, led Roosh to break with the movement. As a frustrated mob that wants to control the sexual choices of all men, he wrote, the "alt-right" was no better than feminism. Despite this, Roosh rushed to support Richard Spencer when he was caught on camera speaking to an audience, which broke into Nazi salutes at his cries of Hail Trump! Hail our People! Hail Victory!
In many ways, white supremacy and male supremacy are one
and the same. A perfect embodiment of this is the concept of
white shariah, a shock-value concept that has
been gathering steam in white nationalist circles.
White shariah is the idea that the submission
and rape of white women by white men is the only way to save
the white race, since white women tend to leave white men
for their non-white counterparts, thus making violence
Before he killed 10 people and injured 14 more on a crowded sidewalk in April, Minassian posted on Facebook that he was a private (recruit) in what he called the Incel Rebellion.
All hail the Supreme Gentleman Elliot Rodger! wrote Minassian, referring to the mass murderer who killed six people in 2014 to punish all females for the crime of depriving me of sex.
Minassian is part of a growing subculture of men calling themselves incels or involuntary celibates. To them, the murderer Rodger is a patron saint. Now, since the Toronto mass killing, they have a new one. Users of the website incels.me have begun changing their avatars to Minassians picture, paying twisted homage to the killer they say could be our next new saint.
That either man should be canonized for his deadly misogyny is both horrifying and utterly predictable.
Male supremacy an extremist ideology we added as a category of hate groups this year has spawned a network of online communities that advocate violence against women. On these sites, women are called foids, or femoids, a term combining female and humanoid to suggest that women are not fully human.
Collectively known as the manosphere, the websites include so-called mens rights forums and how-to communities hosted by pickup artists who advocate rape.
Underpinning it all: the idea that women owe men sex; that women exist purely for their reproductive and sexual capabilities; that men should dominate women.
The extreme hatred among incels has too often been dismissed as mere sexism. Just 10 days after Minassians van rampage, New York Times columnist Ross Douthat recapped arguments that sex is a resource like property and money, one that the sexual revolution intended to be more justly distributed than it is today. He writes:
The sexual revolution created new winners and losers, new hierarchies to replace the old ones, privileging the beautiful and rich and socially adept in new ways and relegating others to new forms of loneliness and frustration.
Douthat like many takes incels at their word that their animus is driven by their inability to find a sexual partner. Thats a mistake.
As our Intelligence Project director, Heidi Beirich, told ThinkProgress, incels have taken this moniker as almost a badge of honor for men who feel like women are not being the docile sex toys for them that they think they should be.
In other words, for incels, its not just about sex. Its about the women supposedly withholding it.
We define hate groups as organizations that attack or malign an entire class of people for their immutable characteristics. Incels like Rodger and Minassian target women in violent attacks because of what they see as the most immutable female characteristic of all: womens sexuality.
I hate women. Truly, they are the scum of the earth. Yet I am still biologically predisposed to want them, wrote a user named Madrame this week on incels.me.
I hold too much contempt to feel attraction to them. I want to riddle them each with 250 with [sic] tec-9 rounds, replied user _incelinside.
The hatred these men feel stems crucially not from their belief that theyre entitled to sex, but from their belief that women are required to give it to them. When women dont, incels weaponize their hate.
It cannot be womens job to pacify men who hate them because of their gender just like it cannot be the job of people of color to disarm white supremacists.
We began tracking male supremacy in 2012. In the wake of the 2016 election, we saw how essential male supremacist ideas were to the rise of the so-called alt-right and formally added male supremacist groups to our hate map the following year.
Now more than ever, its clear that we ignore male
supremacy at our peril.
After Alek Minassians Toronto van rampage that left 10 dead and 15 injured Monday, speculation abounded about his motive. The 25-year-old suspect had not been on the radar of law enforcement, and authorities said the killings were not national security related.
Then a Facebook post emerged from what appeared to be Minassians account. Posted the day of the attack, it hints at an unsettling motive.
Private (Recruit) Minassian Infantry 00010, wishing to speak to Sgt 4chan please, it reads. C23249161. The Incel Rebellion has already begun! We will overthrow all the Chads and Stacys! All hail the Supreme Gentleman Elliot Rodger!
At first glance, the language in the post invites a healthy dose of skepticism. Considering the enthusiasm with which internet trolls spin false narratives after a tragedy, this claim was met with caution. But recent reports suggest it is, in fact, authentic. Multiple news outlets say Facebook representatives have confirmed the veracity of the post, and Toronto Police in a press conference today indicated they also believe it is authentic.
And what the post suggests that Minassian was part of the incel community bears further explanation.
Incels, or involuntary celibates, are part of the online male supremacist ecosystem. The Southern Poverty Law Center added male supremacy to the ideologies tracked on the hate map this year, because of the way these groups consistently denigrate and dehumanize women, often including advocating physical and sexual violence against them. On the internet, the male supremacist ideology takes a few different forms. One of the newest forms is incel.
Incels grew out of the pick-up artist movement, which purports to offer men strategies to persuade, pressure, cajole or trick women into sleeping with them. When those strategies (or game) unsurprisingly proved unsuccessful for many men, they became deeply bitter. To an incel, sex is a basic human right for all men. So the women who deny them that right are committing a heinous and punishable crime.
Elliot Rodger provides the most chilling example of the most violent ends of this nihilistic, spiteful and self-centered ideology. He killed six people and injured 14 others in a mass shooting in California in 2014. He wrote a manifesto blaming women for his loneliness and the fact that he was still a virgin. I'm the perfect guy and yet you throw yourselves at these obnoxious men instead of me, the supreme gentleman, he wrote.
Incels see Rodger as their patron saint. They celebrate his tactics, his body count and, of course, his manifesto, and write wistfully of a violent uprising yet to come. They glorify Rodgers attack using the shorthand, going ER. After last years horrific mass shooting in Las Vegas, incels on Reddit praised Paddock for killing normies, and hastened to claim him as one of their own in the absence of a clearer motive. Shortly after, the r/incel subreddit was banned from the platform.
With the revelation Minassian may be a Rodger admirer, the incel community is alight some with indignation, but most with glee.
"That moment when this random dude killed more people than the supreme gentleman Elliot, said user Crustaciouse on incels.me, where many flocked after the Reddit ban. I hope this guy wrote a manifesto because he could be our next new saint."
Users cheered the fact that Minassian killed more people than Rodger. A person with the username Letting Go opined that the women of Toronto deserved what they got.
As someone who visited Toronto at the beginning of the month, I can see how a man from that city could be driven to kill a bunch of people like that. The women up there are HORRIBLE -- even the ethnic women. It would brighten my day if the majority of the victims were young cunts like the ones that I encountered on my trip.
Letting Go was jubilant when the identity of the first victim, a young woman, was revealed. Its a foid! they said. I have one celebratory beer for every victim that turns out to be a young woman between 18-35.
Foid is short for femoid, a term popular with incels that combines female and humanoid, suggesting women are not fully human, just humanlike.
Some users were less wordy. User mikepence begged, PLEASE BE TRUE PLEASE BE TRUE PLEASE BE TRUE. KyloRen said simply, Joyous day.
BlkPillPres wrote, ER doesnt always have to be violent, it just needs to be strategic and punish normies in some way, they need to be in constant fear for EVERY ASPECT OF THEIR LIFE, killing normies from my perspective is kinda pointless but this is still good, I prefer acid attacks to mass killings though, wonder who is going to do a mass acid attack.
When one user rained on the forums bloodthirsty parade, asking why posters were praising murder, user FeminismsCancer replied, Are you serious? The murder of our enemies will of course be praised. Its rational.
Incels.me had another thread, this one less certain: The Facebook post allegedly made by the Toronto Van Attacker is most likely fake.
Here, users bemoaned the fact that this narrative of the attack would be used against them, some fearing that a newer incel subreddit, a slightly less vicious replacement called r/Braincels, would soon be banned. In an r/braincels Discord chat, Incel Executioner said, We're about to be holocausted lads.
A moderator of r/Braincels posted a disclaimer once speculation began heating up, stating the subreddit does not support, encourage, or glorify any violence or physical harm, or those who commit such crimes.
Its 100% fake news, i think we as a community have the rigth (sic) to sue the media, said use Ub2w, whose signature reads Eugenics = Utopia.
Chadmarco added, I want it to be true for the lulz. And user Total Imbecile complained, Im (sic) 99.9999% sure its fake, but you just have to love how everyone is so eager to bash ugly males, they dont (sic) even care that its fake at this point it seems, theyre (sic) out looking for whatever reason to shit on us.
Details about Minassian and his involvement with incels are still emerging. He was charged Tuesday with 10 counts of first-degree murder and 13 counts of attempted murder, and he will return to court on May 10.
Meanwhile, the misogynists at incels.me continue their feverish discussion. User Crustaciouse began their own thread this afternoon, titled, I laugh at the death of normies. They will die while we survive.
Us incels spend most of our time inside, there's no way we would ever be victims of an attack.
But normies must now live with fear for the rest of their
lives, they can't go to school, the mall, or on a date
without having to fear another incel attack, they
wrote. And they should fear it, this is what happens
when you leave us without any love or
Menstuff® is a registered trademark of Gordon Clay
©1996-2019, Gordon Clay